Monday, November 21, 2016

For a younger priest, who asked me to comment on on recent catastrophic election:

Let us remember the teaching of the holy neo-martyr Dietrich Bonhoeffer, that grace is without price but not without cost. Ours is an apocalyptic faith, which regards times of crisis as times of grace. The End, in fact, is near. Only a fool would predict the final outcome of the current crisis. Whatever it may be, the world as it has been has ended. Platitudes about the sun still coming up are meaningless. [The sun rose every day over Auschwitz — situated, by the way, in a lovely place]. Nevertheless, we understand hope to mean that whatever happens Divine Love is ultimately victorious.
This does not mean that the United States of America will continue as it has been — or even at all. Self-congratulatory faith in America as the “last best hope" is also fatuous. 3,000 years ago the psalmist advised  “put not your trust in princes.” For us, that means not to place our faith in the American experiment, however noble we may imagine it to be. But we can trust in the abundance of grace, costly grace.
Signs of this grace appear all around. Be vigilant for them. Remember the Buffalo herd that came to visit the protectors at Standing Rock. God is with the just. That doesn’t mean success in the short term. It doesn’t mean we will not lose everything. Whatever happens, let us remember that, as long as we are genuinely on the side of the poor, God is with us, because God dwells among them. Fifteen legions of angles fight with us.
Meanwhile, we must not simply wait to see what happens. We must grieve — for a time — but grief can turn into a form of depression. Let us remember Joe Hill’s last words before he was murdered by the State of Utah more than 100 years ago: DON’T MOURN — ORGANIZE! It is time to get busy. Go to meetings. Go to demonstrations. Give whatever you can to organized non-violence resistance. I would say that qualifies as almsgiving, because the end is the defense of the poor and helpless. Intensify all your practices of spiritual warfare, because our struggle is with "spiritual wickedness in high places." So, give alms, fast and pray. Fast twice a week and give the money you save to the poor or to those who defend them. Increase your time -commitment to prayer, standing (or sitting) with the mind and the heart before God. Invoke the Holy Name of Jesus with respirations. And then go out and join the organizing.
We may do all of this in a spirit of joy and gentleness, because we cannot lose. I don’t mean that we MUST not lose, but that we literally CANNOT  lose, because our Divine Savior has already won. Even If We Die, His Victory is our victory.
Yesterday, I promised a Somali friend that if they came to get him, they would have to take me too. As you may know, Trump came to Minneapolis specifically to threaten our Somali community. We had better not imagine that this will never happen. The unthinkable has already happened.
Our apocalyptic roots can serve us well in this evil hour. Whatever the cost, we may lift up our heads and rejoice because our redemption is drawing near.

Blessed are they who consider the poor and needy,
The Lord will deliver them in the time of trouble.
                                                               - Ps. 41
Top of Form


Tuesday, June 7, 2016

Response to a friend on supporting Hillary or Bernie

Ben Kreilkamp,
I would like to congratulate you on the grace and forebearance you have displayed in these conversations, even when your views have been characterized by what appears to me to be sheer projection on the part of the critics. I will try to avoid that as I express my own disagreement. I recognize that we want the same thing, and that our disagreement is strategic.

1) It is far from settled historical fact that the anti-war movement prolonged the Vietnam war. Let's remember that this was the first presidential election after LBJ bid goodbye to the South "for a generation" (it has turned out to be longer), upon passage of civil rights legislation. Except for Texas, the entire South voted for Nixon OR for George Wallace. CA was still firmly in R control. (TX and CA have since changed places, but I expect to see TX flip in my lifetime.) If you look at the popular vote totals, the Wallace vote more than makes up the difference between Nixon and Humphrey. Outside the South, that's white, blue-collar men (AND women) who would have ordinarily voted Dem and could not yet bring themselves to vote Rep. Here is the electoral map and statistics. Let's also remember that Humphrey was forbidden by LBJ to promise a policy change, on pain of Presidential denunciation, Meanwhile, Nixon promised a "secret plan" to end the war.
2) The impatient hippies in Grant Park got their heads and bones fractured by the normal political process of Daley's Chicago - the worst kind of lawless bossism that characterized the politics of our largest cities at the time. Credentialed press and McCarthy delegates got similar treatment in the Convention hall itself. The silly, impatient youth were tired of getting drafted to die in Vietnam. The candidate most likely to change that had been murdered a couple of months before. And a month before that MLK, who was by then the other powerful voice against the war. There was no reason to expect the Center to change that any time soon. As John Kerry was later to ask Congress "how do you ask someone to be the last man to die for a mistake?" I find it hard to dismiss Impatience regarding that request as mere naïveté.
3) The counsel of patience - "wait" - may not be so realistic. Consider that great document of American History, "Letter from Birmingham Jail." King had to answer colleagues and even supporters for precisely the kind of impatience that you appear to find foolish and counterproductive. If our history shows us anything, it is that significant change does not come as a result of waiting.
4) You observe that peaceniks do not win presidential elections. As I wipe the dew from my impatient eyes, I cannot help but notice that the same is true of women and African Americans - until they do. To say that something won't happen because it hasn't happened yet strikes me as dogmatic conservativism, not realism. The only kind of dogma I like is theological. (My faith, by the way, teaches me to "put not [my] trust in princes." Francis Bacon, as a skeptical empiricist, may have found hope an unsatisfying supper; the hope that I try to practice refers to ultimate, cosmic matters and not to the political fortunes of dying empires.)
5) I take your point about the Herculean labor of weaning us from the military-industrial complex. I concede that you may be right about this. The question is whether I should trust a Prince not just BECAUSE of what she says, but IN SPITE of what she says. I continue in amazement that someone with your awful experience wants my enthusiastic support for an admirer of Henry Kissinger. If anyone prolonged the war, it was he. I will support her as a matter of necessity, but without any trace of enthusiasm. That is asking too much. I will, however, hope (in the "unsatisfying-supper" and not the theological sense) that you are right about her intentions, secret though they be. I will grasp at any straw available. Might as well. But without enthusiasm or joy.
6) Finally, about reality and political possibility, I find it interesting to notice the constant expression of surprise from sophisticated and knowledgeable realists, typified by "The New York Times" and the "Washington Post," about the Sanders campaign. ["Something is happening here, and you don't know what it is, do you, Mr. Jones?"] The universe of "mainstream," "insider," or "establishment" political imagination was not prepared for this new reality. When has it ever been? Sanders has forced the expansion of this imagination. So observes Steve Phillips (Brown is the New White), whom you have quoted with approval. I think that you are right about the future significance of this campaign, which I regard as prophetic rather than quixotic.

Saturday, March 5, 2016

Forgiveness and Deliverance from Evil

The tradition speaks of sin as a “contagion”. We are so used to thinking of sin as individual transgression, that we miss the point. As individual transgressors, we ARE all forgiven. That is what for-giveness means. Any debt we think we have incurred by our immoral actions has been forgiven before we were born. The Sin that is “contagious” is a condition – like a disease – that infects us all.
          This is why Sin seems – in some mysterious sense – to be external to ourselves (“The good that I would I do not, the evil that I would not, that I do”). Tradition calls it The Evil One. It is the “Evil’, from which our Lord taught is to pray for deliverance: not a person, like us, but a mysterious fact about us, which Augustine called the mysterium iniquitatis. It is what causes people to do things they never thought they would or even could do. It takes over completely in the chaos of war, when perfectly decent men and women do indescribable things. It is manifest in blood-lust, rape, and torture. But it is present, in principle, whenever one group defines another as alien, whenever one person judges another, whenever an unkind word is spoken, whenever a thought less than charitable is entertained. The difference between these “little sins” and the Nazi annihilation camps is only a difference of degree.
In the face of this horror we have some choice: we can excuse ourselves. “It wasn’t me; I wasn’t in my right mind”. In other words, “the devil made me do it”. And, in a sense, we are right. “The devil” is the condition  in which we all participate, whether we want to or not.   Or we can also seek to justify ourselves, which is worse: “they had it coming”. [This kind of thinking still dominates the American narrative concerning Hiroshima and Nagasaki.]
But there is another choice. Not every soldier becomes a rapist. Not every injured person seeks revenge. We do not have to return evil for evil. In fact Christians are commanded not to do so, and, rather, to love our enemies. As human beings, our life is communal. If we damage another, we damage ourselves; if we condemn another, we condemn ourselves; if we bless and forgive another, we bless and forgive ourselves. Not to do so is to acquiesce in slavery to the mysterium iniquitatis.
          Our Divine Savior has broken the hold of evil on us. When He forgave his executioners, He destroyed the power of the mystery of evil. He also added that the soldiers “(knew) not what they (did)”. They did it, but “the devil made them do it”.  They had been forgiven from before the foundation of the world. The Lord’s prayer for the soldiers was for our edification. Forgiveness of real injury may seem superhuman, but that’s just an excuse – especially for those who look to the Cross for salvation. The Godman’s victory over the Evil One enables us to forgive as He forgave.
          And forgive we must if we are to be delivered from the Evil One – because forgiveness – our forgiveness of our enemies – IS deliverance from evil. That is why the petition for deliverance follows the petition for forgiveness. One leads to the other. In the act of forgiving those who sin against us, we are delivered from the power of evil.* And right after we say the Lord’s Prayer we receive the Blood “which was shed for you and for all, that sins may be forgiven”. By taking Christ’s Death into ourselves in Holy Communion, we receive not God’s forgiveness of our own sins, but the power to forgive those who sin against us. And that divine power destroys the power of evil.

*[NOTE: Hebrew poetry, as in the psalms, relied on repetition and paraphrase. To say “thy will be done” is to say “thy Kingdom come” in another way. Perhaps also, to say “deliver us from evil” is to repeat the petition about forgiveness.]


Thursday, February 18, 2016

Dialogue re: election

You may be right. Your judgment about his ego is just that, though. Hard to verify, not to say gratuitous, I can forgive him for the jet-fighter. I buy his explanation that since it was going to happen anyway, it might as well be in his own state. Isn't this exactly the kind of realism you endorse?

I take your point about MLK running for office. But more interesting to me is the interplay between leaders and movements. Just because he is running for office doesn't mean BS is NOT leading a movement. How would he ever have got this far if there WEREN'T a movement?

Which brings me back to the question of demographics. The FACT is that BS's support varies inversely with age - including among African-Americans and women. I assume you do not consider Michelle Alexander to be seduced by "hot air." How about Keith Ellison? And why, would you say, Elizabeth Warren has not endorsed HC? If this be not a movement, but only an egotistical side-show, how do we account for these facts?,

It is possible - and entirely realistic - to conclude that the Reps are self-destructing and that the emerging political landscape is dominated by forces represented by the two Democrats. Time will tell, and no one can be sure. But the demographics, the best polls, and all the actual elections so far seem to support this conclusion.

Sanders and Revolution (from Facebook dialogue)

To compare Sanders to the Russian revolution is really a stretch. As Noam Chomsky says, he's not really even a socialist (in the classic sense) but a New Dealer. In other words, a gradualist. The center has moved before. It seems obvious to me that it is moving again. I see no reason to deem it "realistc" to insist that the center must stay where it has been in the Reagan/Bush/Clinton era. The facts I face are demographic and an indubitable shift to the left. This is the "political revoluion" of which S speaks. That's rhetoric. It is very far from the Ruaaian revolution.

Nor am I so worried about a "Seven Days in May" coup d'etat or Roman civil war. Like Stalin, I think we have succeeded in minimizing the danger of what he called "Bonapartism" by dividing the military and subverting the enormous bureaucracy by buying off the leadership with revolving doors.

Have a look at Sy Hersh's article in the London Review of Books, in which retired General Staffers openly admitted sharing intel with Assad, via our own allies (Germany, Israel, and Russia). Why is this comforting? It was Realpolitik over Regime-change exceptionalism. The point is that they did it by scrupulously following orders (to share intel with allies). While I am aware that this incident could argue also for the Frankenstein view of an out-of-control military, I think it shows its deeply bureaucratic nature.

As an enormous bureaucracy, the military is conservative and insitutionally stupid, hard to change, but susceptible to manipulation..It is also far from monolithic. As Stalin knew, Bonapartism could be avoided by Caesar's policy: divide et vinces. Personally, I am more afraid - long-term - of secret bureaucracies (CIA/NSA) running under their own clandestine steam through drugs and armament-sales.

Singlepayer health care, free education, and trust-busting to not threaten these spooks at all; The sluggish military bureaucracy even less. It is hardly a "revolution" in the Russian sense, and the horrors of Stalin are not analogous.

As for movements and organization, it seems to me that is exactly what BS is doing. He has said so from the beginning.

Wednesday, February 3, 2016

Sanders and Clinton

{What follows is a post in  Facebook thread, q.v.)

I can empathize with your view that Bernie could win only in another universe. I have a horrible feeling that you are right! On the other hand, in trying to exercise what little may be left of my critical-thinking faculty, I ask myself why I have this foreboding? Your argument is a strong answer. Yet I have to ask - with all respect - is it not based on feeling, as you say the Sanders-supporters' is? (Burned so many times - how could it ever be otherwise?").

This is not entirely feeling (we WERE burned the other times), but the argument rests on presuppositions regarding the Nature of the Universe in which we find ourselves. Basically, it is to say that our politics is always this way. You may be right, but I suggest that it is not merely wishful-thinking to call attention to the big demographic and economic changes. These are what our Marxist friends might call "material conditions". Depending on one's assessment of them, completely hard-headed realists can disagree on the conclusion to be drawn.

I will not accept the practical superiority of a Clinton candidacy on the basis of centrist analysis. This is also what I call "beltway consciousness" or Establishment consensus. I will have to be convinced that these conclusions are, in fact, realistic and not ideological. The fact that pundits repeat them is not enough for me.

I just read a Marxist analysis, criticizing Sanders from the left: essentially the Leninist objection to democratic socialism, that the latter is inseparable from the late-imperialist world order. Sander's utterances on the military and his own pork-barrel vote for military equipment support this criticism. [At least, he was honest enough to say that he hated it, knew it was going to pass in any case, and decided to bring home the bacon for VT!] Anyway, if he can't get elected as a Social Democrat, it is pretty certain that he would do not better as a Leninist!

So, if you have to rely on Clinton's bedrock commitment to women and children, in spite of all the warts, I guess it is fair for me to rely on Sander's bedrock commitment to economic justice and curbing the power of the oligarchy. In either case, as you point out, should they succeed Obama, Congress won't let either of them get much through. 

They will have to build a movement, and I am willing to hope that the time is right for such a movement to build. The youth mobilization is one evidence of that. So are new voters like my Somali friend who asks "Why can't we be like Germany?", where he lived for several years. It is also a fact of American history that sometimes these movements do succeed - against all odds - like the Civil Rights movement. Martin Luther King was, after all, a self-described dreamer.

What better position to build a movement than the Oval Office? Whether or not Sanders wins, I hope he will spend most of his time supporting organizing in congressional races. I think that is what he means by a "political revolution". I don't think Clinton would do that.

It seems to me that Clinton's career of "realistic" compromise has left her in a position of indebtedness to and dependence on the beneficiaries of the present system. That their spokespeople (mainstream media) tell me that she is inevitable is no surprise. Why should I believe them? Why should I not take seriously the many polls that show Sanders actually doing better? Even though these polls may be nearly worthless at this stage, they are at least more objective than my intuitions - or anyone else's - about what is realistic. I would like to see some similar objectivity in support of Clinton.

Wednesday, January 27, 2016

On the One Way to the Father




Walter Hilton (14th Century English mystic) interprets the exclusive-sounding saying “No one comes to the Father except through me.” Jesus is referring to His humanity, which is perfect humility and charity. This is the only “me” who can come to the Father.  In order to come to the Father, we must become like Jesus.


I would add that this has nothing to do with our opinion of Jesus or what we say we believe about Jesus, only being like Him in His humility and love.  Obviously, people can be like Jesus without ever hearing of Him. So, Christ-like people, be they Christian believers or not, can come to the Father.